Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Luke's avatar

Sarah Black naming ten players for Sydney v Carlton, with five matching the coaches' six, shows neatly why recall and strike rate can tell such different stories. Gabelich and Briscomb tying on 52.58%, with only Briscomb clearing 50% on the Jaccard index, suggests the hobby should stick. A narrator reads out everything I publish about Karratha, handy if your eyes have had enough numbers. All my articles: https://lukeybkarratha.substack.com/archive

Jane Aubrey's avatar

Interesting exercise, Lincoln. I’ve reported on elite sport for years, and I wonder whether the disagreements tell us as much as the agreements. Journalists are explaining a contest to an audience. Coaches are judging performances against roles, expectations and tactical instructions that often can’t be seen from outside. I’d be less interested in how closely journalists match the coaches than in what the gaps say about how performance is valued.

1 more comment...

Ready for more?